Donald Trump's Complex Ties with Scotland: A Love Unreturned

Despite his familial connections to Scotland, Donald Trump's reputation among Scots reveals a fractured bond steeped in controversy and environmental clashes.

The Donald Trump we know today as a former president returns to Scotland later this month, a stark contrast from the hotelier who first ventured there in 2006 to announce the construction of his heralded golf course. Back then, he was saluting his Scottish roots, as his mother hailed from the isle of Lewis—a heritage he frequently references. However, unlike past U.S. presidents who have celebrated their roots in Scotland, Trump faces significant disfavor among its residents. Recent polls show a staggering 70% of Scots possess an unfavorable view of the 45th president.

Notably, while John F. Kennedy and Joe Biden have cultivated celebrated images tied to their Irish ancestry, Trump's Scottish connection has devolved into tension and resentment. Though his ancestry is documented—34 American presidents share Scottish roots—his relationship with Scotland has been marred by disputes, particularly surrounding the development of his golf course on the Menie Estate in Aberdeenshire, which he initially described as the world’s greatest golf course. The project stirred significant environmental concerns as it threatened land protected for its unique natural features.

In opposition to Trump's ambitions, local environmental groups and residents mobilized against the ecological impacts of his course. One contentious episode involved his public feud with local residents Michael Forbes and the Milne family, both of whom refused to sell their homes adjacent to Trump's development. Claims made by Trump about the so-called "ugliness" of their homes have only enhanced local animosity and turned these neighbors into symbols of resistance against his project.

Although some officials appreciated Trump's proposals, hoping for the promised economic benefits, skepticism has grown over time as many of his grand plans—including hotel accommodations and residential projects—never materialized. Critics have since raised questions about the true gains from the golf course, which reportedly suffered over £13 million in losses since its opening.

As Trump is set to return to Scotland, anticipation mixes with anxiety regarding public protests responding to his recent polarizing statements and actions. Many communities maintain a vocal opposition toward his policies, with Donald Trump’s presence likely courting protests, amplified by the ongoing discontent among Scots towards the former president.

Scotland stands poised for another tense encounter with Trump, one that illustrates a relationship marked not by affection but by political and social divisions. His past may echo in the attitudes of many Scots, reminding him that while he celebrates his roots, there’s a stark difference in sentiment on the ground.