Skip to main content
Civitas.Global
CrimeIndia

Supreme Court Critiques Air India Crash Response as 'Irresponsible'

The Indian Supreme Court has strongly criticized the aviation authorities for their handling of the aftermath of the deadly Air India crash, which killed 261 individuals. The court contended that the report's premature conclusions and media leaks were both 'irresponsible' and misleading.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Supreme Court Critiques Air India Crash Response as 'Irresponsible'
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

In a significant ruling, the Indian Supreme Court condemned the aviation authorities for their mishandling of the aftermath of the June Air India plane crash that resulted in 261 fatalities. The court highlighted leaks suggesting pilot error as a cause of the crash as 'irresponsible' and criticized the selective release of information regarding the investigation. Calls have been made for an independent inquiry, with heightened scrutiny on the safety of India's airspace.

The highest court in India has strongly criticised the country's aviation authorities for their handling of the aftermath of the Air India plane crash that killed 261 people in June.

Leaving only one survivor, the flight bound for Gatwick airport from Ahmedabad crashed shortly after taking off, killing 242 passengers on board and 19 others on the ground.

The court said it was irresponsible for the aviation authority to suggest through leaks to the media that pilot error had caused the disaster.

It called on Indian prime minister Narendra Modi for the government's response before it rules on a case filed by activists demanding an independent investigation.

The court said the way the aviation body released its preliminary report into the Boeing Dreamliner's crash was selective and piecemeal.

The report, published on 12 July, said that just seconds after take-off fuel supply to the engines was cut off.

The report also said that one of the pilots is heard asking the other why did he cut off in a cockpit voice recording, with another pilot responding that he did not do so.

The recording doesn't clarify who said what. At the time of take-off, the co-pilot was flying the aircraft while the captain was monitoring.

One of India's Supreme Court judges said in court that suggestions that the pilots deliberately shut off fuel supply were very unfortunate and irresponsible.

The crash has left many questioning the safety of India's airspace.

The chief of India's aviation authority, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), has defended the safety record of the country, telling the BBC in July that India's skies have always been safe.

That same month, the DGCA uncovered 51 safety violations at Air India in the preceding year, as part of its annual audit of the country's airlines.

The families of four passengers who died on the plane filed a lawsuit in the US against planemaker Boeing and aircraft parts maker Honeywell, accusing the companies of negligence.

The lawsuit accused the companies of doing nothing despite being aware of the risks of the aircraft's design.

Topics

More on this story