Monsignor Jamie Gigantiello has been stripped of all responsibilities after the Diocese of Brooklyn found serious mismanagement beyond allowing the filming of Carpenter's video, which featured objectionable imagery within church premises.
Priest Dismissed After Controversial Music Video Filmed in Church

Priest Dismissed After Controversial Music Video Filmed in Church
A New York priest faces removal and scrutiny following pop star Sabrina Carpenter's provocative music video shoot in his church.
In a response to public concern and investigations launched, Gigantiello's dismissal reflects a broader issue of administrative oversight within the church. His conduct not only raised eyebrows due to the music video but was compounded by unapproved financial transactions and misuse of church funds.
The controversy erupted after Carpenter filmed her music video for "Feather," which showcased provocative scenes including one with a crucifix. The diocese expressed its disapproval and confirmed Gigantiello’s removal when mismanagement allegations surfaced.
Announcement of the priest's removal noted that investigations by Alvarez & Marsal and Sullivan & Cromwell LLP revealed multiple violations of Diocesan policies. Bishop Robert Brennan stated that the investigation showed Gigantiello misused church funds, transferring nearly $2 million to accounts associated with a former staff member of New York City Mayor Eric Adams, who is currently facing multiple criminal charges.
Gigantiello's administrative duties were already on thin ice prior to the video incident and he has since been withdrawn from fundraising and management roles within the Church following persistent scrutiny. While he admitted to a "lapse in judgment," he has not publicly responded to the other serious allegations against him.
The controversy erupted after Carpenter filmed her music video for "Feather," which showcased provocative scenes including one with a crucifix. The diocese expressed its disapproval and confirmed Gigantiello’s removal when mismanagement allegations surfaced.
Announcement of the priest's removal noted that investigations by Alvarez & Marsal and Sullivan & Cromwell LLP revealed multiple violations of Diocesan policies. Bishop Robert Brennan stated that the investigation showed Gigantiello misused church funds, transferring nearly $2 million to accounts associated with a former staff member of New York City Mayor Eric Adams, who is currently facing multiple criminal charges.
Gigantiello's administrative duties were already on thin ice prior to the video incident and he has since been withdrawn from fundraising and management roles within the Church following persistent scrutiny. While he admitted to a "lapse in judgment," he has not publicly responded to the other serious allegations against him.