In brief
In a significant ruling, a New Mexico judge has temporarily halted the federal death penalty case of Labar Tsethlikai, citing the adverse impacts of the current government shutdown on funding for public defenders. This decision underscores the broader implications of the shutdown on the judiciary and defendants' rights across the nation, as defense teams struggle to cope with extended payment delays and dwindling resources.
SANTA FE, N.M. (AP) — A judge in New Mexico has halted a federal death penalty case due to the ongoing U.S. government shutdown and resulting funding shortages for specialized public defenders. This situation has persisted since the summer and raises grave concerns regarding access to justice for defendants.
The Trump administration initially sought the death penalty for Labar Tsethlikai, implicated in a series of kidnappings leading to sexual abuse and fatalities, as part of an effort to address justice for missing and murdered individuals in Native American communities. Tsethlikai, 52, hailing from Zuni Pueblo, has entered a plea of not guilty.
As death penalty cases require substantial preparation costs, delays in Tsethlikai's case reflect growing concerns about the judiciary's functioning amidst the funding crisis. Attorney Ryan Villa noted, 'If you want to pursue the death penalty, you can’t do it without funding the defense.'
The push to reinstate federal capital punishment follows a moratorium initiated by President Biden. Of the 23 cases authorized by Attorney General Pam Bondi, eight were dismissed by courts, with Tsethlikai's being the only one currently stalled due to the shutdown.
Ripple Effects of the Shutdown
Villa expressed concerns about the trend of public defenders in New Mexico shifting away from indigent cases in pursuit of more reliable income, compounding the challenges for defense attorneys to meet their constitutional obligations.
The federal judiciary reported that funding ran out in early July for compensating court-appointed defense attorneys under the 1964 Criminal Justice Act, which ensures legal fees for defendants who cannot afford representation. Such attorneys represent roughly 40% of federal defendants across the country.
Rather than relief, the new federal budget year commencing in October brought the continuation of the shutdown. Milagros Cisneros, a supervisory assistant federal public defender in Arizona, highlighted the dire situation, explaining that the payment delays affect not only attorneys but also critical support personnel like investigators and transcriptionists.
Constitutional Rights Under Threat
In a ruling last week, U.S. District Court Judge David Herrera Urias emphasized the fundamental right to defense, marking that the shutdown significantly hampers this essential principle. Previously an attorney affiliated with the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Urias was nominated by Biden and secured confirmation in 2021.
In response to the motion for halting the case, federal prosecutors criticized it as an unnecessary tactic to delay justice, claiming that it prevents them from commenting further on the matter.
Public defenders have contended that thorough investigations into Tsethlikai’s background and mental health have ground to a halt due to insufficient funding, leading to additional strain as some team members have tapped into personal savings to sustain their work.
Resources Dwindling Nationwide
Across California, a federal court alert indicates that appointed defense attorneys will remain unpaid until new funding is approved, with almost 70% of eligible attorneys refusing new cases due to financial instability. Attorney Anthony Solis, representing these attorneys, estimated that only 20 out of 90 such attorneys are currently accepting cases during the shutdown.
A recent motion filed in California seeks dismissal for a lead defendant in a significant racketeering and murder case, sending a clear message to the government that immediate improvements are necessary.



