In brief
In a landmark ruling, U.S. District Judge William Smith determined that the requirement for states to cooperate on immigration enforcement to secure disaster funding is unconstitutional. The judge's decision highlights the risks that arbitrary conditions jeopardize federal disaster assistance essential for public safety. Rhode Island Attorney General Peter Neronha hailed the ruling as a reaffirmation of the rule of law against executive overreach.
BOSTON (AP) — A federal judge in Rhode Island has ruled unconstitutional the conditions imposed by the federal government that required states to collaborate on immigration enforcement actions in order to qualify for disaster relief funding from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).
The ruling follows a federal lawsuit filed by a coalition of 20 state Democratic attorneys general, which claimed that the Trump administration had threatened to withhold billions in disaster-relief funds unless states complied with specific immigration enforcement actions.
U.S. District Judge William Smith, in granting summary judgment to the plaintiffs, described the contested conditions as 'arbitrary and capricious' and indicated that these actions are unconstitutional because they are 'coercive, ambiguous, unrelated to the purpose of the federal grants.'
Attorney General Peter Neronha of Rhode Island has noted that this ruling is a victory for the rule of law and asserts that the President cannot selectively choose which laws to follow.
Smith's permanent injunction states clearly that the federal administration may not impose illegal immigration conditions on federally allocated funding meant for emergency services like disaster relief and flood mitigation.
The states involved in the lawsuit argued that historically, they relied on federal funding to effectively prepare for and respond to disasters. However, conditions necessitating state resources for immigration enforcement jeopardized funding crucial for mitigating natural disasters such as earthquakes, floods, and wildfires.
The Department of Homeland Security's actions aimed to undermine the established emergency management funding process, which the plaintiffs argued was both unconstitutional and a violation of the Administrative Procedure Act.
The government's defense that the conditions were moot because they had excluded several programs from compliance with immigration conditions was dismissed by the court, emphasizing that the fundamental issue remains a matter of constitutional principle.
Overall, this ruling underscores the importance of maintaining federal-state boundaries while securing necessary funding for effective disaster management and public safety initiatives.


