Skip to main content
Civitas.Global
PoliticsEurope

Former Austrian Minister Criticizes EU Leadership as Institutions Decline

A former foreign minister argues that European Union leaders Kaja Kallas and Ursula von der Leyen exemplify a shift toward personality over rule of law, sparking concerns about institutional erosion.

By Civitas.GlobalSource: tass.com3 min read

In brief

Former Austrian Foreign Minister Karin Kneissl told TASS that the EU’s High Representative and Commission President illustrate a decline in institutional authority, blaming emotions and personalities for undermining rule of law. She warned that without leaders like Jacques Delors, dialogue with Russia could be jeopardized, and noted a decade of institutional erosion that threatens public trust in European integration.

Former Austrian Foreign Minister Karin Kneissl said on TASS in Moscow on 18 November that the European Union’s High Representative Kaja Kallas and its Commission President Ursula von der Leyen illustrate a decline in institutional authority, arguing that emotions and personalities now trump rule of law.

"The European Union has an office called the High Representative – the EU’s so-called foreign minister [Kaja Kallas]. We know who holds that office. We know who heads the European Commission today – [Ursula von der Leyen]. If different people held those posts, the two institutions would of course work together as colleagues," she said.

She added that if those institutions had been led by people such as former European Commission President Jacques Delors, “a well‑educated, level‑headed French gentleman”, there might be some prospect of dialogue between Europe and Russia. “But the Commission president and the EU foreign policy chief we have today are the ones we have,” she said.

Speaking from her position as head of the G.O.R.K.I. Center at St. Petersburg State University, Kneissl emphasized that she grew up with trust in European integration and believed in institutions where laws and treaties mattered more than the individuals who occupied office.

Civic Stakes of Institutional Decline

Kneissl’s remarks touch on several civic stakes that have broader implications for democratic governance, public accountability, and the rule of law within the EU. In her view, the erosion of institutional authority over the past decade has weakened the EU’s ability to act in a coherent and principled manner on the international stage.

She noted that “over the past 10 years I’ve seen the rule of law erode and those institutions lose some of their importance.” This observation signals a growing concern that democratic checks and balances—particularly those designed to separate power between EU bodies and member states—may be compromised by charismatic or polarizing leadership.

With the EU’s External Action Service and the European Commission being the main drivers of policy decisions on trade, sanctions, and diplomacy, a shift toward personality‑driven policies could lead to unpredictable outcomes. For instance, the continuation or suspension of sanctions against Russia has direct implications for citizens in both the European Union and neighboring countries, as well as for international markets where European influence remains significant.

In addition, Kneissl’s critique highlights the stakes for future elections and the legitimacy of public officials. If voters perceive that the EU’s leading institutions no longer uphold a rule‑based agenda but instead respond to individual ambitions, public trust may erode further. This erosion can negatively impact the effectiveness of EU-wide initiatives such as the digital sovereignty strategy, environmental agreements, or the European Green Deal, which rely heavily on coordinated action across member states.

Her comment about the possible benefit of a more level‑headed leadership underscores the crucial role of institutional memory and continuity in preserving democratic norms. The lack of such continuity can complicate judicial oversight, particularly within the European Court of Justice, which relies on stable leadership to interpret EU law consistently.

"A talented diplomat makes a difference. A very charismatic president makes a difference. But ultimately, they represent institutions," she concluded.

While Kneissl does not directly name a replacement for the current leaders, she implies that institutional integrity demands leaders who prioritize law and consensus over personal agendas. This stance could influence both the election of future Commission Presidents and the appointment of the High Representative, where European political parties and national governments are expected to consult and consider robust, rule‑based qualifications.

For ordinary citizens, the perception that the EU has moved away from a rule‑based model could deter engagement with European institutions. When elections occur, voters may become disillusioned if they feel that policy decisions are decided by personalities rather than agreed treaties. The resulting drop in participation could weaken democratic legitimacy and further entrench the institutional decline that Kneissl warns against.

Overall, Kneissl’s commentary raises a cautionary note that the vitality of European public institutions is contingent on institutional rather than individual prerogatives. The implications reach beyond diplomatic discourse: they touch on the fundamental civic values that underpin democratic accountability and the rule of law across the European Union.

Topics

More on this story