Unique Fine for Speakerphone Use at Nantes Train Station Sparks Debate

David, a 54-year-old man, is fighting a €200 fine issued by SNCF for using loudspeaker mode while on a call at Nantes station. He claims the fine, initially set at €150, was increased after he refused to pay immediately. The incident, which has drawn public attention and highlighted cultural attitudes towards loud phone calls in public spaces, is currently under legal dispute.

A man fined €200 for using loudspeaker during a call at Nantes train station is challenging the penalty in France. Identified only as David, the 54-year-old stated on BFM TV that he was speaking to his sister when SNCF staff approached him. Initially warned that he would receive a €150 fine if he did not deactivate the loudspeaker, he refrained from complying, believing it was a joke. SNCF confirmed the fine and alleged the interaction escalated leading to the increased cost due to David's refusal to settle on the spot.

Despite David's account, SNCF indicated that their security personnel are empowered to issue fines when passengers disturb public peace. They assert the fine was raised from €150 because it wasn't paid immediately. The incident has prompted discussions about noise regulations in public transport areas, despite no national law explicitly banning loud phone calls in France.

Public sentiment toward loudphone use is quite stern; a recent YouGov survey revealed that 86% of Britons find using speakerphone in public unacceptable. Different countries have varied responses—some train operators in the UK implement quiet zones, emphasizing a reduction in noise, while Japan and South Korea have similarly strict cultural guidelines promoting silence on public transport.

The conversation continues as David explores legal avenues against the penalty, with broader implications for public etiquette and noise regulation in shared spaces.