Skip to main content
Civitas.Global
PoliticsThe Trump administration is seeking support from various countries to reform the global asylum system, claiming it is being abused. Deputy Secretary of State Christopher Landau discusses potential changes during the U.N. General Assembly, raising concerns among human rights groups about the implications for refugees.

Trump Administration Encourages Global Allies to Reform Asylum Practices

During a recent U.N. General Assembly, the Trump administration urged countries to support a crackdown on asylum abuse, emphasizing the need for reform in the global asylum system.

Source: AP2 min read

In brief

The Trump administration, led by Deputy Secretary of State Christopher Landau, convened a meeting with representatives from several countries to address what it sees as rampant abuse of the global asylum system. The U.S. proposed significant reforms, including conditions on asylum and an emphasis on returning to home countries after temporary protection. Critics from human rights organizations warn that these changes threaten the integrity of the current asylum framework.

NEW YORK (AP) — The Trump administration pitched several other countries Thursday on its view that the global system for seeking asylum, in effect since World War II, has been rampantly abused and urged them to join the United States in cracking down on such migration.

Deputy Secretary of State Christopher Landau led the discussion on the sidelines of the U.N. General Assembly alongside representatives from Kosovo, Bangladesh, Liberia and Panama. Landau’s gathering allowed American officials to gauge early support and interest for what could be a massive revamp of the asylum system.

“If you have hundreds of thousands of fake asylum seekers, then what happens to the real asylum system?” Landau said in his opening remarks. “Saying the process is susceptible to abuse is not xenophobic; it is not being a mean or bad person.”

The U.S. said changes must, at a minimum, embrace asylum as a temporary status and dictate that those seeking protection should eventually return home. The Trump administration also emphasized that there is no right to receive asylum in a country of choice and that decisions are governed by individual nations, not multinational organizations.

Human rights groups watched from the sidelines with unease.

Bill Frelick, Human Rights Watch’s director of refugee and migrant rights, said the U.S. proposal “looks like the first step in a bid to tear down the global refugee system.” He faulted the proposal for not embracing a core principle of the current system that people should not be sent to countries where they face persecution.

The U.S. has been the top destination for asylum-seekers by far since 2017, with Germany a distant second, according to 2024 figures from the U.N. refugee agency. President Donald Trump and his allies say people with weak cases have abused the system to gain entry to the United States, obtaining work permits while their cases take years to wind through backlogged immigration courts.

The U.S. adheres to a global asylum system first laid out in the 1951 Refugee Convention and enshrined into U.S. law in 1980.

People seeking refuge in the U.S. are able to apply for asylum once they are on American soil, regardless of whether they came legally. To qualify, they have to show a fear of persecution in their own country for specific reasons, such as race, religion, nationality, social group membership, or political opinion. Refugees meet a similar standard by applying abroad.

Once someone is granted asylum, they can’t be deported, they can work legally, bring immediate family, apply for legal residency, and seek U.S. citizenship. It offers a permanent future in the U.S.

The number of people coming to the U.S.-Mexico border seeking asylum has ballooned in recent years, overloading immigration courts and leading to cries that the system is being abused by people coming for jobs or other reasons that don’t meet the standards for asylum.

Topics

More on this story