In brief
In a controversial decision, Ontario's Marineland is considering euthanasia for 30 beluga whales after the Canadian government blocked their relocation to a theme park in China. The park cited financial difficulties and a lack of alternatives for the whales, while animal welfare advocates have condemned this potential action. Marineland has been under scrutiny for years over animal care issues, raising questions about the future of these marine mammals.
A Canadian amusement park is threatening to euthanise 30 beluga whales after the government blocked its request to send them to China.
Marineland in Ontario had hoped to offload the cetaceans on a theme park in Zhuhai, after suffering years of animal welfare concerns and financial woes.
But their transfer was denied by the Canadian government last week over concerns they would face similarly substandard treatment as public entertainment.
The park then asked for federal funding to be able to continue caring for the animals - but this was denied, being branded inappropriate by Fisheries Minister Joanne Thompson.
In the absence of funding as it winds down operations, Marineland has now said it may have to put the belugas to sleep, according to the New York Times and CBC News.
It reportedly said this was a direct consequence of the minister's decision.
The park is said to have told ministers that it was in a critical financial state and unable to provide adequate care for the whales, having been closed over the summer while it removed the animals still there.
But Thompson said Marineland's lack of a viable alternative home for the belugas did not entail the Canadian government should foot the bill for their care.
Marineland had hoped to send the belugas to Chimelong Ocean Kingdom in Zhuhai, which sits in between Hong Kong and Macau in China.
Thompson denied its export permit, saying the strengthening of fisheries legislation in 2019 that made it illegal to use whales and dolphins for entertainment prohibited the move.
I could not in good conscience approve an export that would perpetuate the treatment these belugas have endured, she said.
To approve the request would have meant a continued life in captivity and a return to public entertainment.
Criticisms of Marineland date back several years, and in 2020 Animal Welfare Services opened an investigation into the park.
It found that 12 whales at the park had died over a two-year period and declared all the park's marine life to be under distress.
Some 20 whales have died at the marine park since 2019 - five of them in 2024, according to news agency the Canadian Press.
As visitors to the park began to plummet and Marineland became mired in financial crisis, it won an appeal in February to remortgage its own land to fund moving its animals while it looked for a new buyer.
Animal welfare campaigners have expressed outrage at Marineland's conduct and the possibility the whales could be killed.
Camille Labchuk, executive director of Canadian animal rights group Animal Justice, said Marineland had a moral obligation to fund the future care of these animals, adding that threats to euthanise the animals were reprehensible.
World Animal Protection called on the provincial government to seize the belugas, saying it must show leadership and ensure these animals receive the best possible care.
