Skip to main content
Civitas.Global
PoliticsMiddle East

Trump's Role in Gaza Ceasefire: Impact and Limitations

While Donald Trump's influence was pivotal in securing a Gaza ceasefire, experts caution that this agreement isn't a foundation for lasting peace. The complexity of Middle East tensions persists.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Trump's Role in Gaza Ceasefire: Impact and Limitations
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

Donald Trump's recent diplomatic efforts in Israel and Egypt have been praised for facilitating a ceasefire and hostage exchange with Hamas, but analysts assert that this agreement lacks the structure needed for a genuine peace process. Observers highlight that while Trump played a crucial role in the ceasefire, deeper political will and sustained diplomatic effort are essential for lasting peace in the region.

Donald Trump's quick trip to Israel and Egypt was the victory lap he wanted.

Anyone watching the speeches he made in Jerusalem and Sharm el-Sheikh, could see a man luxuriating in his power - enjoying the applause in Israel's parliament, and in Egypt, basking in the fact that so many heads of state and government had flown in.

One veteran diplomat in the room said it looked as if Trump saw the role of the world leaders there as extras on his film set.

Trump's message at Sharm was, in effect, that he had created a historical turning point.

All I've done all my life is deals. The greatest deals just sort of happen… That's what happened right here. And maybe this is going to be the greatest deal of them all, he said.

Observers might also have had the impression from the speeches that the job is done. It is not.

Without question, Trump can claim credit for the ceasefire and hostage exchange deal. Qatar, Turkey and Egypt used their leverage with Hamas to force it to accept.

That made it a joint effort, but Trump's role was decisive.

Without his push to demand Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's agreement to terms that he had previously rejected, the deal would not have been signed.

It helps to recognise what the deal is – and what it isn't.

The agreement was for a ceasefire and an exchange of hostages for prisoners. It is not a peace agreement, or even the start of a peace process.

The next phase of the Trump 20-point plan requires an agreement filling in the gaps of the framework which declares that the Gaza Strip will be demilitarised, secured and governed by a committee including Palestinians.

It will report to a Board of Peace chaired by President Trump. Significant work needs to be done on the detail needed to make that happen.

The Gaza agreement is not a route map to peace in the Middle East, the ultimate and so far, unreachable destination.

Topics

More on this story